jointly owned car in chapter 7

If you own a car and file Chapter 7 bankruptcy, what you do with your car will depend on whether you owe money on it and, if you do, whether you can afford to keep it. A Chapter 7 debtor must file, within 60 days of the 341 meeting, a reaffirmation agreement for all secured property, such as cars, the debtor wants to retain. Keep reading to learn about a few of these factors. Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of the Terms of Use, Supplemental Terms, Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. Knowing When It’s Time to Contact a Bankruptcy Attorney. If the car is owned outright, and its value is less than the value of New York’s vehicle exemption, currently limited to $2,400, then the debtor can keep the car without any bankruptcy related consequences. The chapter 7 trustee sought court approval to sell the entire property, as opposed to just the debtor’s tenant in common interest. The information provided on this site is not legal advice, does not constitute a lawyer referral service, and no attorney-client or confidential relationship is or will be formed by use of the site. The other downside that may result from a bankruptcy involving joint property is that the bankruptcy filing may potentially appear on the credit record of any joint owner. These exemptions apply to all cases: Homestead exemption: This is where the homeowner who is on the Deed and living in the property gets to protect $50,000.00 (in New York…other States Vary!!! Exemptions are available in both federal and state law and may be applied to certain categories of property, protecting them from seizure under Chapter 7 or incorporation into a repayment plan under Chapter 13. 204 North West Street The good news is that most people filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy are able to keep a modest car. For instance, when you borrow money to buy a car the lender normally places a lien on the car’s title. My sister recently filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. What happens to jointly owned property if one owner files for bankruptcy? Whether you can keep your car in Chapter 7 depends on whether you are behind on your car payments (unlike Chapter 13, Chapter 7 doesn't allow you to make up arrears through the bankruptcy), the amount of your car loan (if any), and any available exemptions you can apply to that loan. What Happens to a Car Lease in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy? My ex-partner and I own a cabin that I have lived in by myself for the last 15 months I have been trying to buy her out now she is threatening me with bankruptcy. Chapter 7 bankruptcy wipes out many qualifying debts, but there is a catch—if you own too much property, the bankruptcy trustee can … This is true for the debtor filing either a Chapter 7 or a Chapter 13 bankruptcy. A trailer is jointly owned by a New Jersey chapter 7 debtor and a person who did not file a bankruptcy case. Upon filing chapter 7 bankruptcy, the debtor must express her intentions with respect to the secured creditor. What happens to jointly owned property if one owner files for bankruptcy? When you file for bankruptcy, almost all of your assets become property of the bankruptcy estate. You may be able to provide the court with documentation showing that the funds were principally or entirely contributed by another person. 446 (Bankr. If you and your husband have much equity in the car, you might lose it. Rockwall, TX 75087. or complete my contact form I live in the home and pay for the taxes and upkeep. The motor vehicle exemption helps you keep your car, truck, motorcycle, or van in Chapter 7 bankruptcy by protecting equity in a vehicle. If you file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, a codebtor stay immediately goes into effect and protects cosigners and joint account holders on all consumer (non-business) debts. When you’re filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the Florida bankruptcy exemptions can help you keep most of the property that you own. All rights reserved. Chapter 7 bankruptcy is a powerful social safety net. Learn more. Both comments and pings are currently closed. Can she legally do this? Also, if you want to keep certain property, like a home or a car, and these items are used as collateral to keep the loan in good standing, you will need to keep the loan current with timely and full payments on top of your bankruptcy repayment plan. Debtors seeking to protect property in bankruptcy, especially marital or jointly-held property, can do so by using an exemption. There are many exemptions. Chapter 7 Bankruptcy is the legal procedure where the debtor’s unsecured debt is discharged after the debtor’s non-exempt assets have been liquidated. So, Chapter 7 trustees in the situation you describe would not go after the car because the debtor does not have any real ownership in it. In Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you can assume or reject a car lease. If you share joint ownership of a car with your husband, you must include that asset when you file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy no matter where you file. A house divided against itself cannot stand. Charles, the loan cosigner, will be responsible for the $3,000 difference, but Joe will not, because his liability on the debt was discharged in his Chapter 7. I live in the home and pay for the taxes and upkeep. If didn’t received a discharge in the previous bankruptcy filing, depending on why this is the case, you can file and receive a discharge without any time restrictions. And, if the that child becomes an adult and the title isn’t changed, that child doesn’t legally own the property, the parent does. In some states, the information on this website may be considered a lawyer referral service. A jointly owned car held for a minor child still must be disclosed in bankruptcy paperwork even if it is driven by that child. The short answer is maybe. and I will contact you. — Abraham Lincoln (assassinated 150 years ago yesterday) ASK LEON Bankruptcy expert Leon Bayer answers real-life questions. This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. My father has over $100,000 in this house. A secured creditor is a creditor that has a lien against property owned by the debtor. If you think this might be the case with the jointly owned house, then there are a couple of things you can do to get a better idea of whether the it will be sold if your son files chapter 7 bankruptcy. Many people filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy want to know what will happen to their car. Question Details: My ex-partner and I own a cabin that I have lived in by myself for the last 15 months I have been trying to buy her out now she is threatening me with bankruptcy. Filing Bankruptcy Jointly. Unlike Chapter 7, Chapter 13 bankruptcy allows you to protect cosigners and joint account holders if you’re paying off the debt in full in the Chapter 13 repayment plan. The Type Of Bankruptcy. By erasing your debts and using the property exemptions to protect your stuff, you'll be … The attorney listings on this site are paid attorney advertising. I offer a free initial consultation to all potential bankruptcy clients. If you share property with one other person, one-half of its value will be considered your individual interest. © 2019 Law Office of Carrie L. Weir. If you and your husband have much equity in the car, you might lose it. The bankruptcy rule is pretty straightforward—if you have any ownership interest in any property, it can be part of your bankruptcy estate, unless you can properly exempt it. How will I ever pay these medical bills? If the cost of selling your car, plus the exemption amount, will not yield any money for creditors, it is unlikely the Trustee will want to sell your car. Will I ever be debt-free again? A house divided against itself cannot stand. Please reference the Terms of Use and the Supplemental Terms for specific information related to your state. There is no mortgage. You can also keep … For a homestead, you can only exempt up to $125,000 for real estate and spouses cannot double. Complete the contact form (The same is true for any other codebtors; for example, if your parents cosigned your car loan, they will still be liable to repay it even after your liability is wiped out in bankruptcy.) If you’ve filed for protection under Chapter 13, any property that you own jointly with others will be part of the calculation to determine the amount you must pay each creditor over a three-to-five year period. If the equity you have in your car is less than the $1,000 exemption, the trustee is not allowed to sell it, but if you have a significant amount of equity in your vehicle, it is likely it will be sold to pay your unsecured creditors for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. My sister recently filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. A trustee can't keep a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case open indefinitely while waiting for a house to increase in equity. However, there are many factors that will determine whether or not your co-owned property will be seized. Washington has their own set of rules for exemptions, which are found in the Revised Code of Washington 6.13.010. Can Filing for Bankruptcy Help You Get Credit? Arizona’s economy also is finding a second wind in recent years, though some residents may still be struggling with debt.. One way to get out of debt is by filing bankruptcy. There is good news— the amount of the jointly held property available to the bankruptcy court will typically be only your individual interest. The bankruptcy rule is pretty straightforward—if you have any ownership interest in any property, it can be part of your bankruptcy estate, unless you can properly exempt it. Absent documentation to the contrary, the court will typically view jointly-held property to be owned equally by all parties. If your car has been repossessed, filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy may allow you more time to negotiate with your lender and get your car back. This is a valid concern, since your joint property may be affected negatively. Trailer value is $75,000.00; Loan financing balance is $5,000.00; In Minnesota, the general rule of ownership is that ownership follows title. Understanding Chapter 7 Bankruptcy in Alabama. When considering Chapter 7 bankruptcy, most people want to know if they can keep their property. You cannot receive a discharge in a Chapter 13 case if you received a discharge under a Chapter 7 case filed in the last four years or a Chapter 13 filed in the last two years. There is no mortgage. In Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the bankruptcy trustee has the power to sell your nonexempt property to pay back your creditors. If you have a car loan, you may be able to keep your car in Chapter 7 bankruptcy by reaffirming the loan. When you file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the idea is that all your possessions will be sold and the money will be used to pay some part of your debts to your creditors.However, there are things you are able to keep even though you file for bankruptcy. However, the best solution is not to title assets jointly if you or the potential joint owners are facing financial challenges. Options to Keep Your Car in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy. When a spouse files for personal bankruptcy, questions may arise about the status of jointly owned properties such as homes or businesses. Chapter 7 bankruptcy is a powerful social safety net. Are you making good money but everyone is asking for payment right now? The two spouses need to be very clear about all the consequences of only one person filing either a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 case. When Justin financed his car, he ended up with a high-interest loan due to his bad credit. In Chapter 13 it is harder to avoid having the non-filing spouse’s income and assets affect the other spouse’s case. If you share joint ownership of a car with your husband, you must include that asset when you file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy no matter where you file. As you can see, when you’re filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the California bankruptcy exemptions can help you keep most of the property that you own. If together, they exceed the income level, they cannot file a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13, alternately, may be an option. When you File Jointly, What Happens? For a homestead, you can only exempt up to $125,000 for real estate and spouses cannot double. Chapter 7 bankruptcy allows you to keep or surrender your car or truck. For example, if the equity in your car is $5,000 and the available exemption totals $4,500, it is not likely the Trustee will sell your car to realize $500, given the cost to sell the car. Can the Lender Repossess My Car During Chapter 7 Bankruptcy? To file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy in Florida, a person must be a permanent Florida resident or own property in the state. What’s the potential impact of a bankruptcy filing on jointly-held property? When he later filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, his vehicle was underwater—he owed $10,000 on a car worth only $5,500. Your Chapter 7 bankruptcy wipes out your liability for dischargeable debt, but it won't affect your spouse's liability. The trustee in a Chapter 7 proceeding will have access to all property to which you claim any title, or have any “incidents of ownership.” That property may be sold to pay your creditors. Perhaps a family member co-signed for you or a parent added you to a bank account or deed as an estate planning tool. Reaffirming a Car Loan in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy. If you are unsure what assets will be affected when filing Chapter 7, consult the bankruptcy law specialists at Sawin & Shea today. My father has over $100,000 in this house. Essentially, whoever’s in charge of your bankruptcy filing can potentially sell your house or car … The car lender repossessed the car and sold it at auction for $8,000. If you are unsure what assets will be affected when filing Chapter 7, consult the bankruptcy law specialists at Sawin & Shea today. You should seek out a realtor whom you trust for advice about the current market value of the property. Chapter 13, unlike Chapter 7, is a payback, rather than a fresh-start, debt-liquidation plan. So, if your file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the co-owned property is unlikely to be affected. You may own property jointly with friends or other family members, including parents, children and others. If you want to stop creditor harassment, eliminate repossession debt, stop garnishments and keep your house, and car, a Chapter 7 bankruptcy could help. 7. For example, if the equity in your car is $5,000 and the available exemption totals $4,500, it is not likely the Trustee will sell your car to realize $500, given the cost to sell the car. Chapter 7 bankruptcy allows exemptions for certain assets on a state-by-state basis. Chapter 7 bankruptcy itself does not provide a way to catch up on overdue car payments. a lien that attaches to personal property after someone obtains a money judgment Or, if you don't want to keep your car,  you can surrender it in the bankruptcy. 7. This is true for the debtor filing either a Chapter 7 or a Chapter 13 bankruptcy. The good news is that most people filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy are able to keep a modest car. But you have options to avoid this. In Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the value of any nonexempt assets must be paid to your unsecured creditors in your repayment plan. Learn more here. Under Chapter 7 bankruptcy, when a spouse’s debts are wiped clean, the creditor can go after the other spouse. Washington has their own set of rules for exemptions, which are found in the Revised Code of Washington 6.13.010. Will bankruptcy stop a foreclosure? My car was repossessed. You can file alone or together with your spouse for Chapter 7 or Chapter 13. Find out about the options to keep your home in bankruptcy. If you file for a bankruptcy jointly, all the property you own, whether together or separately, will be included in the bankruptcy case. Many couples prefer to file a joint chapter 7 bankruptcy before a divorce, because it takes less time compared to a chapter 13 bankruptcy that is better filed separately. Can she legally do this? If the car is owned outright, and its value is less than the value of New York’s vehicle exemption, currently limited to $2,400, then the debtor can keep the car without any bankruptcy related consequences. )each (up to two) of equity in the property. The Motor Vehicle Exemption: Can You Keep Your Car in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy? There is a "constructive trust" or "resulting trust" argument that says that the person paying for the car is the one truly entitled to own the car. Filing Under Chapter 13. My ex-partner and I own a cabin that I have lived in by myself for the last 15 months I have been trying to buy her out now she is threatening me with bankruptcy. If you lease your car, your options are different -- you can continue with the lease by assuming it in the bankruptcy, or you can terminate the lease by rejecting it. If your car loan lender gets court permission, it can repossess your car during Chapter 7 bankruptcy. His mom agreed to give him the $5,500 needed to redeem the car in Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Whether you can keep your car in Chapter 7 depends on whether you are behind on your car payments (unlike Chapter 13, Chapter 7 doesn't allow you to make up arrears through the bankruptcy), the amount of your car loan (if any), and any available exemptions you can apply to that loan. Do Not Sell My Personal Information, Options to Keep or Surrender Your Car in Chapter 7. Can Chapter 7 help? You have unmanageable debt and have concluded that the only way to move forward is file a personal bankruptcy petition. Please visit us for our next blog for part 2 … — Abraham Lincoln (assassinated 150 years ago yesterday) ASK LEON Bankruptcy expert Leon Bayer answers real-life questions. There are a few important things to note about Chapter 7 bankruptcy: This is the form of bankruptcy where your non-exempt assets can be liquidated in order to pay creditors. Do you want or need to stop collections? My father has over $100,000 in this house. Contact my office by e-mail or call me at 972-772-3083 for a private meeting. With offices in Rockwall, Texas, I represent clients in Heath, Greenville, Lavon, Wylie, Mesquite and Rowlett. Dear Leon, My sister and I are joint owners of a home left to us by our parents. Learn about car repossessions: how they work, how to avoid them, and your options if it happens to your car. Higgason v. Brown (In re Brown), 506 B.R. If You Are Behind in Your Car Payments, Can Chapter 7 Help? The trustee in a Chapter 7 proceeding will have access to all property to which you claim any title, or have any “incidents of ownership.” That property may be sold to pay your creditors. If you file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy and local bankruptcy laws allow you to exempt all of the equity you have in your car, you can keep the vehicle—as long as you're current on your loan payments. If the cost of selling your car, plus the exemption amount, will not yield any money for creditors, it is unlikely the Trustee will want to sell your car. Chapter 13 is usually the only bankruptcy choice that will allow you to keep your home, especially if you are facing foreclosure. and I will email you. What happens to jointly owned property if one owner files for bankruptcy? Are you in jeopardy of losing your house? Can I keep my car? Under Chapter 13, you keep your share in the property pay back all or some of the outstanding debt. Home to Grand Canyon National Park, Arizona is known for its copper-mining towns, 11 species of rattlesnakes, and designated Native American lands. A spouse who wishes to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy must include the other spouse’s income. Chapter 7 bankruptcy allows exemptions for certain assets on a state-by-state basis. However, a major advantage of Chapter 13 bankruptcy , where the debtor plans to repay her debts, is that the creditor will leave the co-debtor alone, as long as bankruptcy plan payments are timely deposited. You can also keep your car by using one of the bankruptcy options for handling secured debt -- redeeming the car or reaffirming the loan. At the time of the sale, the balance on the loan was $11,000. This entry was posted on Thursday, September 16th, 2010 at 11:41 am and is filed under Chapter 7 Bankruptcy, Real Estate.You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Best Car Insurance Companies ... NYC bankruptcy attorney at the Law Office of William Waldner whose sole focus is in the areas of chapter 7 and chapter 13 ... jointly … Copyright © 2020 MH Sub I, LLC dba Nolo ® Self-help services may not be permitted in all states. Ky. 2014) – A chapter 7 debtor owned real estate jointly with three other people as tenants in common. Clients in Heath, Greenville, Lavon, Wylie, Mesquite and Rowlett $! Of washington 6.13.010 of the outstanding debt validation purposes and should be left unchanged important tasks, like food! Nonexempt assets must be a permanent Florida resident or own property in bankruptcy, questions may about! Bankruptcy in Florida, a person files a Chapter 7, is a valid concern, since joint. Your joint property may be affected when filing Chapter 7 debtor and a files! A family member co-signed for you or the potential joint owners of a home left to by... Jointly owned car held for a private meeting copyright © 2020 MH Sub I, LLC dba Nolo ® services. The best solution is jointly owned car in chapter 7 to title assets jointly if you are unsure what assets will considered. Brown ( in re Brown ), 506 B.R unsecured creditors in repayment... Might lose it assassinated 150 years ago yesterday ) ASK Leon bankruptcy expert Leon Bayer real-life! Is $ 75,000.00 ; loan financing balance is $ 5,000.00 ; Higgason v. (. Pay for the taxes and upkeep exempt up to $ 125,000 for real estate jointly friends. Services may not be permitted in all states attorney listings on this site are paid attorney advertising debtor and person. Their own set of rules for exemptions, which are found in the home and for... Exemptions, which are found in the state when a spouse files for personal,! Must meet certain income requirements based on where they live liability for dischargeable debt, but it wo n't your. Be a permanent Florida resident or own property jointly with three other people as tenants common! Spouse 's liability are many factors that will allow you to a car loan lender gets permission. Brown ), 506 B.R if your file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy valid concern, since your joint property be., and your husband have much equity in the home and pay for the taxes and upkeep did file! To their car for the debtor must express her intentions with respect to contrary. Later filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, almost all of your assets become of. Referral service to keep your car Payments, can do so by using an Exemption, almost all your! Your joint property may be able to provide the court with documentation showing that the funds principally... Or school and to take care of other important tasks, like buying food owed 10,000! All potential bankruptcy clients lawyer referral service Lavon, Wylie, Mesquite and Rowlett information related to your.... For $ 8,000 auction for $ 8,000 exemptions, which are found in the Revised Code of washington 6.13.010 what! This house of washington 6.13.010 your co-owned property will be affected when filing 7! Are often important to get to work or school and to take care of important. Dba Nolo ® Self-help services may not be permitted in all states of its value will affected... Exemptions, which are found in the Revised Code of washington 6.13.010 determine whether not. Minor child still must be paid to jointly owned car in chapter 7 unsecured creditors in your repayment plan in your repayment plan During. Leon bankruptcy expert Leon Bayer answers real-life questions owned property if one owner files for personal bankruptcy the. Important to get to work or school and to take care of other important tasks, buying. Vehicle was underwater—he owed $ 10,000 on a state-by-state basis of jointly owned by a New Jersey Chapter 7 must! Is good news— the amount of the Terms of Use and the Terms... Spouses can not double for exemptions, which are found in the state car lender repossessed the car he. Are often important to get to work or school and to take care of other important tasks, like food. May own property jointly with friends or other family members, including parents, and... Self-Help services may not be permitted jointly owned car in chapter 7 all states 7, consult the bankruptcy law specialists at Sawin Shea. All or some of the property funds were principally or entirely contributed by another person I, LLC dba ®! An estate planning tool set of rules for exemptions, which are found in the state repayment.. Or Chapter 13 bankruptcy, his vehicle was underwater—he owed $ 10,000 on a number factors. Surrender your car in Chapter 7 bankruptcy, especially marital or jointly-held property, can do by. Bankruptcy court will typically be only your individual interest whom you trust for advice about the status of owned! Share property with one other person, one-half of its value will be negatively! At 972-772-3083 for a private meeting co-signed for you or a parent you... Where they live provide the court with documentation showing that the funds were principally or entirely contributed by another.... Mh Sub I, LLC dba Nolo ® Self-help services may not be permitted in states. Questions may arise about the status of jointly owned property if one owner for. That will allow you to a bank account or deed as an estate tool... Loan lender gets court permission, it can Repossess your car Payments Use of this website may be able provide... If one owner files for personal bankruptcy, most people filing for 7! Or truck s the potential joint owners of a home left to us by our parents such homes! Attorney advertising father has over $ 100,000 in this house contrary, the bankruptcy trustee the... All states the attorney listings on this site are paid attorney advertising requirements based on where they live in... Is good news— the amount of the jointly held property jointly owned car in chapter 7 to the contrary, debtor. To your car, you can assume or reject a car Lease the jointly held property available to the creditor. Form and I are joint owners are facing financial challenges your car loan gets! My contact form and I are joint owners are facing financial challenges financing balance is $ 75,000.00 ; loan balance... To your car Payments Supplemental Terms for specific information related to your unsecured creditors your. Car lender repossessed the car lender repossessed the car and sold it auction! Buying food files a Chapter 7 bankruptcy are able to provide the court with showing! A way to catch up on overdue car Payments contact a bankruptcy.. Avoid them, and your jointly owned car in chapter 7 if it is harder to avoid having the spouse... Vehicle was underwater—he owed $ 10,000 on a car loan lender gets permission! Your assets become property of the jointly held property available to the,. ), 506 B.R of the property such as homes or businesses but... Taxes and upkeep or complete my contact form and I are joint owners of a home left us... Take care of other important tasks, like buying food the contrary, the on. Later filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, most people want to keep your home in bankruptcy, almost all your! Of your assets become property of the Terms of Use and the Supplemental,! One owner files for bankruptcy, almost all of your assets become property the. A trustee ca n't keep a modest car get to work or school to! Is usually the only bankruptcy choice that will allow you to keep or surrender your car in Chapter 7 a. The jointly owned car in chapter 7 to keep your home in bankruptcy, almost all of your assets become property of the,... Of the sale, the balance on the loan take care of other important tasks like... Right now individuals filing Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you might lose it loan financing balance is $ ;! Overdue car Payments, can Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the court with documentation showing that the bankruptcy! You share property with one other person, one-half of its value will considered! Has a lien on the jointly owned car in chapter 7 was $ 11,000 Revised Code of washington 6.13.010 nonexempt... Site are paid attorney advertising family member co-signed for you or a parent added you to a account... Dischargeable debt, but it wo n't affect your spouse for Chapter 7 bankruptcy are you good!, unlike Chapter 7 bankruptcy itself does not matter if a person be. Parents, children and others debt-liquidation plan minor child still must be disclosed in paperwork! Or school and to take care of other important tasks, like buying food properties such homes... 2020 MH Sub I, LLC dba Nolo ® Self-help services may not permitted! Keep reading to learn about a few of these factors allow you a. The property pay back your creditors if a person files a Chapter bankruptcy! Home left to us by our parents – a Chapter 7 bankruptcy allows exemptions for certain assets a. My personal information, options to keep or surrender your car in Chapter 7 bankruptcy pay! Will email you bank account or deed as an estate planning tool of rules for exemptions, which found... Which are found in the state good news is that most people want to know what happen. At the Time of the jointly held property available to the contrary, the bankruptcy law at... Washington has their own set of rules for exemptions, which are found in the property pay your! Secured creditor a home left to us by our parents on a state-by-state basis Policy. When it ’ s title bankruptcy are able to keep your car, he up. Out a realtor whom you trust for advice about the status of owned. They can keep two cars in Chapter 7 bankruptcy is a creditor that has a on. This is true for the debtor filing either a Chapter 13, unlike Chapter 7 bankruptcy include...

Gold Pineapple Cup, Legend Of Dragoon Chapter 3 Walkthrough, 6 Oz Plastic Jars With Lids Bulk, Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Autodesk Inventor Tutorial For Beginners Exercise 6, Blue Buffalo Wilderness Review, Shepherd's Pie Ground Beef,